Back Cooking & Baking
The Secret to Making Perfect Deviled Eggs Every Time

The Secret to Making Perfect Deviled Eggs Every Time

Words Heather Ramsdell

Deviled eggs are delicious, but they’re not always the easiest egg dish to crack. Learn how to make your best deviled eggs ever with our classic recipe and 10 easy tips and tricks to get it right every time you make them.

Ever wonder what to do with too many leftover deviled eggs? Probably not, because leftover deviled eggs don’t even exist.

They are too delicious, and otherwise too fun to eat. But peeling eggs is not as fun as eating them. If only peeling were always like that magical time when you get the whole shell off in one piece. It’s stressful to pick off eight or ten thousand tiny shell fragments, tearing hunks of the white off as you go. Still, the peeling doesn’t even always deter us.

Popping a deviled egg into your mouth, with its sharp, creamy rich yolk mousse nestled in their slippery modernist-looking egg-white vessels, somehow seems to make up for the inconvenience and next time you start to make deviled eggs, you can’t remember about all the shell fragments, and the rest of the process is pretty straightforward.  But there are tricks to make it simpler.

With some egg wisdom you can make the whole process breezy. When that happens, you might make them every time someone comes over to visit you, and many of the other weekend and weekdays, in between, including each and every brunch and holiday party you go to this year. In a few years, you might saturate your fan base and wonder what to do with leftovers. But until then, have at it.

This recipe is classic because mustard, mayo and vinegary hot sauce is a good flavor combo. But you can change things around and add pinches of bacon or curry or scallions and everything bagel seasoning if you like that. There is at least one variation for every day of the year.

Use Older Eggs

Older eggs are easier to peel than fresh ones: in an older egg, the membrane between the shell and the white is more likely to stay in one piece and stick to the shell rather to the egg white.

pressure cooker eggs

Stack to Steam

Steaming uses less water and takes the same amount of time. When you steam eggs, you can stack them directly on the Egg Rack.

steaming eggs

Under Pressure

An electric or standard pressure cooker makes consistently good hard boiled eggs that don’t have a sad, grey outer-yolk because they are not over cooked. Most electric pressure cookers beep at you when the eggs are done, so, all you have to do is dunk them in a bowl of frigid water (AKA an ice bath), wait 15 minutes (don’t refrigerate them). Then tap both ends and roll them around and peel off the shell in big, satisfying pieces.

Tender Whites and Crumbly Yolks

Timing is important here. An ideal deviled egg has a tender, non-rubbery white and a moist yet crumbly yolk that is yellow all the way to the edge. Luckily, unlike some other proteins, eggs are sold in standard sizes, and there is no guesswork. They take the same amount of time to cook in boiling water every time. Using an actual timer, (instead of estimating) is a good move that’ll get you just-right eggs every time.

Keep Your Cool

When you plunge eggs into a big bowl of ice water, you bring their temperature down quickly and stop the cooking process.

You’re Crushing It

You can push yolks through a potato ricer to pulverize them before you mix in the dressing. If you have a food processor, pop the yolks and dressing ingredients in there an pulse for an extra creamy and fluffy filling.

Neatness Counts

Yolk smears are not dangerous but deviled eggs look better without them. If things got messy during cutting and yolk removal, swish the cut whites in and let them dry before piping in the yolk mixture.

Season to Taste (Literally)

Before transferring your yolk mixture to a piping bag, taste it. It should be seasoned enough to flavor the yolk mousse but also the mild tasting whites.

Pipe with a Baggie

Piping rather than spooning will help you get really neat looking eggs.  Squeeze the filling into the egg-white hollows with a sealable bag with a tiny corner snipped off. Make sure that you put the tiny corner right into the trash.

The Cup Trick

Put the bag cut corner down, into a cup and fold the cuff over the glass before filling. This stabilizes the bag and keeps the filling from sneaking out of the hole as you fill it.

Pipe Down

When piping a swirl (this also applies to cupcakes, work with the tip of your bag close to the surface and lift up only to finish the center peak. That will give you a more controlled swirling technique.

Make Ahead

Make the filling and the eggs ahead of time, and even plan to bring it to a potluck. Just keep the whites and yolks separate and pipe just before you are ready to eat.

Plus, check out our All-Purpose Guide to Cooking Eggs and tips on how to use an egg poacher.

Classic Deviled Eggs

Makes 12 servings, Recipe Courtesy of Heather Ramsdell:

Ingredients

12 large eggs

1/2 cup mayonnaise

1 tablespoon Dijon mustard

2 teaspoons apple cider vinegar

1/2 teaspoon hot sauce

1/4 teaspoon cayenne pepper, plus more for garnish

Flaky salt, to taste

Instructions

  1. Fill a large bowl with ice and water. Put 1 cup water into a pressure cooker or multi-cooker. Put a steamer insert into the cooker and arrange the eggs on it, stacking them if needed. Close the lid and turn the valve to seal. Bring to full pressure then cook 5 minutes. Manually release the pressure, then transfer the eggs to the ice bath to stop them from cooking. Let them cool 15 minutes.
  2. Crack both ends of the shells and tap all over, then peel in running water and discard the shells. Halve the eggs. Pop out the yolks and arrange the whites on a serving tray. Put the yolks into the bowl of food processor and pulse them to pulverize, or push them through a potato ricer into a bowl. Add mayonnaise, mustard, vinegar, hot sauce, cayenne and salt to taste. Process or whisk vigorously until very creamy, scraping down the sides of the bowl. Taste and adjust seasoning if needed.
  3. Snip a small corner from a sealable plastic bag and put the filling into it. Pipe the filling into the egg-white hollows. Sprinkle the yolk with a tiny pinch of cayenne and the whites with a few flakes of salt, and serve immediately.

Shop this post

OXO Good Grips Triple Timer OXO Good Grips Triple Timer Shop Now
OXO Good Grips One Stop Chop Manual Food Processor OXO Good Grips One Stop Chop Manual Food Processor Shop Now
Avatar
By Heather Ramsdell

You might also like

5 Comments

  • Leave a CommentReply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Stay in the loop.

    Sign up and be the first to hear about exclusives, promotions and more!